Is Roaring Brook Lake Polluted?
Yes — Roaring Brook Lake in Putnam County, New York is on the EPA's Clean Water Act 303(d) impaired-waters list (2022 assessment cycle). It is cited for Metals (other than mercury). No cleanup plan (TMDL) has been completed yet. "Impaired" is a legal designation, separate from the lake's A–F water-quality grade: it means at least one designated use (such as swimming, aquatic life, or fish consumption) does not meet state standards for the listed pollutant.
EPA 303(d) Listing
| On 303(d) impaired list | Yes |
| Cleanup plan (TMDL) | Not yet written |
| Assessment cycle | 2022 |
| EPA IR category | 5 |
| Location | Putnam County, New York |
Pollutants Cited
- Metals (other than mercury) — listed by EPA as exceeding water-quality standards for at least one designated use.
What this means for using Roaring Brook Lake
Roaring Brook Lake's listing is driven by contaminants that build up in fish (Metals (other than mercury)), so the practical impact is on eating the fish, not on swimming. Follow the state fish-consumption advisory for New York. An impairment listing does not mean the lake is closed — most impaired lakes remain open for boating and swimming. It means a specific pollutant exceeds a standard for a specific use. Roaring Brook Lake carries an overall water-quality grade of C — see the full breakdown on the lake report. The official EPA assessment is available in the ATTAINS waterbody report.