Does Toby Creek hold wild trout?

Yes. The state classifies Toby Creek as Class I (wild, self-sustaining) across 2.07 miles of stream. That classification means natural reproduction, not stocking. Source: Wisconsin DNR Classified Trout Streams.

Toby Creek

Wisconsin. Classified Class I (wild, self-sustaining) by the state across 2.07 miles.

State Trout Classification

Classification	Class I (wild, self-sustaining)
Classified length	2.07 miles

Source: Wisconsin DNR Classified Trout Streams.

Fly fishing rivers →Wisconsin trout water →Wisconsin lakes →

Conditions: USGS NWIS (public domain). Classification: Wisconsin DNR Classified Trout Streams.