1
Stolley Pit Lake
Clay County, Iowa · 26.7 mi from Five Island Lake
- ++1.1 ft water clarity
- +Lower phosphorus (48 vs 82 µg/L)
Cleaner Lakes Than Five Island Lake
3 lakes with lower nutrient and algae readings within 30 miles, ranked by the size of the improvement and by proximity.
Five Island Lake carries nutrient and algae readings on record. Within 30 miles, 3 lakes read lower. Stolley Pit Lake (Clay County, 26.7 mi away) is the closest meaningful upgrade.
Reviewed by LakeQuality Editorial Team · Updated
2
Lost Island Lake
Palo Alto County, Iowa · 12.4 mi from Five Island Lake
- +Lower phosphorus (68 vs 82 µg/L)
3
Lower Gar Lake
Dickinson County, Iowa · 27.5 mi from Five Island Lake
- +Lower phosphorus (71.5 vs 82 µg/L)
Stays via Stay22
Where to stay near Five Island Lake
Compare cabins, hotels, and vacation rentals around Five Island Lake in Iowa. The 3 lakes above sit within 30 miles, so one base reaches them all. Switch the map to Satellite to see how close each stay is to the water.
Top-rated places to stay near Five Island Lake
Prices for Oct 23–25, 4 adults. Change dates on the map below.
Availability and prices from Stay22 partners (Booking.com, Vrbo, Expedia). We may earn a commission from bookings, at no extra cost to you.
Planning a trip to Five Island Lake?
Get lake water-quality updates plus the best cabin & lodging deals near Five Island Lake — straight to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Reading the cohort
Only 3 lakes within a 30-mile radius read cleaner than Five Island Lake on nutrients and algae. The narrow set of options reflects either a fairly clean lake to begin with or a region without a wide range of cleaner alternatives, so the trip-planning decision is more constrained than the headline "cleaner lakes nearby" suggests.
The nearest cleaner alternative — Stolley Pit Lake in Clay County — sits 26.7 miles from Five Island Lake, putting it firmly in "destination trip" rather than "neighborhood swap" range. The water-quality gap has to be the deciding factor; for a casual outing, Five Island Lake is the practical choice and the cleaner options are reserved for purpose-specific visits.
Each lake's nutrient and algae readings — total phosphorus, total nitrogen, chlorophyll-a, and turbidity — are shown beside the EPA National Lakes Assessment 2022 condition class for that lake's own ecoregion, so a reading is compared against the lakes it would naturally resemble. LakeQuality publishes no letter grade. Lower readings mean measurably less nutrient and algae in the water, not better scenery or access: the lake with the clearest, lowest-nutrient water can have worse boat-launch facilities or shoreline access than a neighbor, so the comparison is one input alongside the rest of trip planning. How the readings are classified is on our methodology page.
How this list is built
Sampled lakes on LakeQuality carry readings from EPA Water Quality Portal samples — nutrients and algae measured against EPA National Lakes Assessment ecoregion classes. Secchi is shown, not scored. To suggest cleaner alternatives, we filter lakes within 30 miles to those with strictly lower nutrient and algae readings, then rank by the size of the improvement with a small proximity tiebreak. Cross-state and limited-data lakes are excluded so the list stays locally relevant.